Consider a new manager who says, “I'm not comfortable giving direct feedback.” A researcher avoids presenting unfinished work because uncertainty feels unprofessional. A quiet colleague turns down an opportunity that would require speaking more often.

These may be honest descriptions of how each person feels. But a feeling can become a limit before the person has tried a different approach. “That's not me” ends the discussion just when there might be something useful to learn.

The Mirror in the Yes-Way asks us to look at how we act now and what our responsibilities require next. A clear picture of your habits should help you decide what to practice.

A familiar piece of advice

In Hamlet, Polonius tells Laertes, “to thine ownself be true.”[1] The line travels well as advice, but a character's speech in a play needs interpretation. It cannot settle what a manager owes a colleague or what a new role will require.

Researchers use authentic leadership in a more specific sense than “do what feels natural.” Walumbwa and colleagues described four components: self-awareness, openness in relationships, balanced consideration of information, and an internal moral perspective.[2] That is a more demanding account than simply expressing a preference.

What the research debate tells us

George Banks and colleagues found substantial overlap between authentic and transformational leadership in their meta-analysis.[3] This raises questions about how much the two research constructs explain separately. It does not show that honesty is unimportant.

Mats Alvesson and Katja Einola also challenged what they saw as excessive positivity in authentic leadership research, questioning its assumptions, measures, and claims.[4] Their critique is part of a research debate, rather than a verdict on every leader who values authenticity.

For a working leader, the debate invites more concrete questions. Are people getting a clear account of the situation? Have I considered evidence against my view? Am I meeting the responsibilities of my role? Feeling like yourself does not answer those questions.

Learning through provisional selves

Herminia Ibarra studied professionals moving into more senior roles. They observed role models, tried unfamiliar ways of working, and assessed the results. She called these experiments “provisional selves.”[5] Her later essay on the authenticity paradox explains how a fixed idea of who you are can get in the way of that learning.[6]

A reserved person can practice opening a meeting. Someone uncomfortable with criticism can learn to describe a problem respectfully. The behavior may feel rehearsed at first because it is being learned. That feeling does not, by itself, make the behavior dishonest.

William Fleeson and Joshua Wilt found that feeling authentic was not simply a matter of behaving in line with one's usual personality traits. People could feel authentic while acting differently from their typical patterns.[7] The study concerns a feeling, not a test of moral integrity, but it challenges the idea that familiarity is the only guide to being yourself.

These studies do not tell you which behavior is right in every role. They give you reason to try an unfamiliar approach and assess what it actually does.

Practice and character

In Analects 12.1, Confucius links humaneness with self-restraint and a return to li, often translated as ritual propriety.[8] The idea belongs to a broader ethical and social tradition; reducing it to workplace etiquette would miss much of its meaning.

It offers a useful question, though: could practicing a form of conduct help change the person practicing it? Adam Seligman and colleagues explore a related possibility in their account of ritual as an “as if” world of shared forms.[9] This is a way to think about practice, not evidence that a particular leadership exercise works.

In String Leadership at EntrLabs, the concern is how people develop through conduct they can examine and practice. A description of someone's current tendencies can inform that work. It should also leave room for change.

What should remain consistent

Experimenting becomes a problem when winning approval is the only measure of success. You can become better at impressing people while doing less to meet your responsibilities.

Keep the distinction between learning a method and creating a false impression. Preparing a clear explanation is useful. Pretending to know what you don't know is dishonest. Practicing considerate behavior can help you keep a commitment; claiming a commitment you have no intention of honoring cannot.

The Yes-Way's commitments to service, protection, and keeping promises give the practice a purpose. Judge a new behavior by whether it helps you meet those commitments and by its effect on other people.

Test a behavior you have ruled out

  1. Choose one behavior your role needs that you tend to avoid. Make it specific: end a meeting with agreed responsibilities, ask for clarification when you are unsure, or raise a concern before a deadline.

  2. Watch two people who handle that task well in different ways. Borrow one useful method and try it in a suitable situation. Preparing what to say is part of learning; you don't have to pretend it comes easily.

  3. In your Evening Review, a short reflection at the end of the day, record what happened. Did the method help? What felt awkward? Ask a trusted observer whether it made the work clearer or more useful, rather than whether you seemed different.

After several attempts, adapt the method to your own voice or try another. The experiment should give you information, not an obligation to imitate someone indefinitely.

You can keep your commitments while changing how you act on them. Your previous habits are a starting point, not the final word.

Notes and sources

  1. Shakespeare, William. Hamlet, Act 1, Scene 3 (Polonius's advice to Laertes). https://shakespeare.mit.edu/hamlet/hamlet.1.3.htmlBack to passage ↑
  2. Walumbwa, Fred O., Bruce J. Avolio, William L. Gardner, Tara S. Wernsing, and Suzanne J. Peterson. "Authentic Leadership: Development and Validation of a Theory-Based Measure." Journal of Management 34, no. 1 (2008): 89–126. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206307308913Back to passage ↑
  3. Banks, George C., Kelly Davis McCauley, William L. Gardner, and Courtney E. Guler. "A Meta-Analytic Review of Authentic and Transformational Leadership: A Test for Redundancy." Leadership Quarterly 27, no. 4 (2016): 634–652. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.leaqua.2016.02.006Back to passage ↑
  4. Alvesson, Mats, and Katja Einola. "Warning for Excessive Positivity: Authentic Leadership and Other Traps in Leadership Studies." Leadership Quarterly 30, no. 4 (2019): 383–395. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.leaqua.2019.04.001Back to passage ↑
  5. Ibarra, Herminia. "Provisional Selves: Experimenting with Image and Identity in Professional Adaptation." Administrative Science Quarterly 44, no. 4 (1999): 764–791. https://doi.org/10.2307/2667055Back to passage ↑
  6. Ibarra, Herminia. "The Authenticity Paradox." Harvard Business Review, January–February 2015. https://hbr.org/2015/01/the-authenticity-paradox Author's text: https://herminiaibarra.com/the-authenticity-paradox/Back to passage ↑
  7. Fleeson, William, and Joshua Wilt. "The Relevance of Big Five Trait Content in Behavior to Subjective Authenticity: Do High Levels of Within-Person Behavioral Variability Undermine or Enable Authenticity Achievement?" Journal of Personality 78, no. 4 (2010): 1353–1382. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6494.2010.00653.xBack to passage ↑
  8. Confucius. Analects 12.1. Translated by James Legge. Paraphrased. https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/3330/pg3330-images.htmlBack to passage ↑
  9. Seligman, Adam B., Robert P. Weller, Michael J. Puett, and Bennett Simon. Ritual and Its Consequences: An Essay on the Limits of Sincerity. New York: Oxford University Press, 2008. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195336009.001.0001Back to passage ↑